Why Reformation Day Should Be a Day of Mourning

Every year, on October 31st, a few Reformed Churches in my area gather at a local pub, grab a few beers, and celebrate Reformation Day. The night is filled with friendship, laughter, theological conversation, and usually a strongly Protestant (by which I mean anti-Roman Catholic) sermon.

Reformation Day celebrates the myth of the Reformation. By “myth,” I don’t necessarily mean “false,” but instead mean a story of significance. And that’s exactly what the stories told on Reformation Day are. The basic story is that the visible church (the Roman Catholic Church) had gone astray somewhere on its march through time and history and that those at its helm, the bureaucratic apparatus, had become so blinded to the truth of the Gospel of Christ that they substituted it for a false gospel of works. That was, at least, until Martin Luther, in his billowing monastic robes, nailed his 95 theses to the door, and ignited a movement that would rock Christendom and loose the free message of grace by faith alone upon the world.

Reformed theologian Peter Leithart commented on this ritual during his 2010 Reformation Day sermon:

“If defending the Reformation means nothing more than repeating the Reformation slogans or assenting to (or claiming to assent to) the Reformation confessions; if defending the Reformation means we carry on with business as usual… then the Reformation has become a kind of tribalism. If that is what being Protestant means, then the Reformation has been turned upside down and inside out… If being Protestant means simply trying to preserve or recapture the sixteenth century, then the Reformation is already dead and deserved to die.” 1

The point of the Reformation was to reform the church. The church became stagnant, proud, and deaf to the needs of the individual members of each congregation. The leadership had lost itself and was only shaken by Luther, when he blew the entire situation up. But this explosion, meant to effect change, has in modern times been reduced to a tribal birthday party carried out by people stuck in their ways, interested only in the echo chamber of their own traditions and personal histories. If that’s the Reformation, then it has, indeed, failed.

This attitude isn’t just on Reformation Day; it also shapes the very theology of the Protestant church. In 2003, Leithart pointed out a situation where a Reformed elder complained that N.T. Wright’s view of forensic justification was Romanism because even Roman Catholic theologians now admitted justification is forensic. Leithart notes:

“Five hundred years ago, Protestants would have been dancing in the streets to hear that Catholic theologians admitted that justification is a forensic act. They would have declared Luther’s protest a success and gone on building a unified Christendom. Today, maintaining the separation of Catholic and Protestant has become so important that even theologians who teach forensic justification are suspect because Catholics teach that too.”

Doors are closed theologically not because they are or are not biblical, but because they are too Catholic.

Beyond Reformation Day and theological appetites, Protestant tribalism has had a major impact on the life of the average, everyday Christian. Take Lent, for example. A vein runs through Reformed traditions that bans all holidays except the Lord’s Day (Sunday), simply because the high times of the traditional church cannot be found in Scripture and resemble Roman Catholic traditions 2. But banning Lent has led to a repetitive ticking of the Christian calendar, which has harmed the faith. As Leithart notes, the suppression “of Lent did not produce perpetual Easter; it produced a perpetual Lent… When the Lenten spirit is not given its due, it has threatened to engulf the whole year.” 3 Without fasting, ashes, or purple robes, there can be no high time. Everything in the life of the church is reduced to a flat, mechanical repetition, year after year.

But not all Reformed traditions prevent high and low times in the life of the church. The Westminster Confession, for example, allows for such times (times of feasting and times of fasting), and the more time goes by, the more I wonder: why have we turned October 31st into a feast of self-congratulation instead of a solemn fast?

The Girardian Mechanism of the Festival and “Not Being Catholic”

Humans love to celebrate their divisions. In fact, you can almost say this is one of the chief characteristics of human beings. The celebration of our divisions spans culture, religions, and time. To explain this, it is helpful to explore the insights of René Girard and his theory of mimetic desire 4.

The chief identifying characteristic of humanity is mimetic desire: a desire that arises through the imitation of others. These “others,” called “models” or “mediators,” filter and mediate the world for imitators, shaping their desires. Mimetic desire is not inherently evil. Our parents are our first models, teaching us how to learn, love, and deal with the world. But if our desire to be like our models is strong enough, we will want what they have; we will covet.

This covetousness transforms our models into our rivals. When rivalries cannot be resolved, frustrations build. Girard calls this situation a scandal (from the Greek and Hebrew for “stumbling block”). Unconsciously, the group—previously fractured into rivalries—turns on a single victim and sacrifices them. This vents the building frustration, allowing the community to restore its peace and avoid its own guilt. As Girard puts it, the “community affirms its unity in the sacrifice, a unity that emerges from the moment when division is most intense… Suddenly the opposition of everyone against everyone else is replaced by the opposition of all against one.” 5

What is fascinating about this mechanism is that the reenactment of this surrogate-victim, through ritual, is religious in nature. Girard comments:

“Any phenomenon associated with acts of remembering, commemorating, and perpetuating a unanimity that springs from the murder of a surrogate victim can be termed ‘religious.’” 6

Elsewhere, he explains why communities do this:

“I contend that the objective of ritual is the proper reenactment of the surrogate-victim mechanism; its function is to perpetuate or renew the effects of this mechanism; that is, to keep violence outside the community.” 7

This scapegoat mechanism maps directly onto the Reformation. Girard observes:

“Religion always scandalizes in periods of decomposition because the violence that had entered into its composition is revealed as such and loses its reconciliatory power. Human beings are soon moved to make religion itself into a new scapegoat, failing to realize once more that the violence is theirs. To expel religion is, as always, a religious gesture—as much so today when the sacred is loathed and abhorred as in the past when it was worshipped and adored. All attitudes that do not recognize the founding victim are never anything more than opposing errors, doubles that eternally exchange the same gesture…” 8

The “period of decomposition” for the Reformation was the Late Medieval period of Rome. By the early 1500s, the medieval Roman apparatus (indulgences, bureaucratic penance, corrupt hierarchy) was decomposing. Its sacred rituals had lost their power to reconcile and instead “scandalized” Europe. Faced with this scandal, the Reformers didn’t just reform the church; they made the religious fabric of the Roman Church the new scapegoat. By expelling Rome as a corrupt monster, Protestantism experienced a sudden rush of internal unity. This explains why “not being Catholic” became the glue that holds rival Protestant groups together.

But this was a mistake. By expelling Rome the way it did, Protestantism became Rome’s mirror image. Rome excommunicated and burned heretics to protect its institutional unity. Protestants did the same, using schism, confessional shibboleths, and mutual excommunication against each other (Luther vs. Zwingli at Marburg, Calvinists vs. Lutherans, Presbyterians vs. Baptists). They became Rome, but on a fractured, legionary scale.

This mirroring of Rome completely undermines the integrity of the Reformation. Leithart gives an example of a dispute between Calvinists and Lutherans over the breaking of the bread. These two groups fought by claiming the other was more Roman Catholic than they were. Leithart says:

“Lutheran and Reformed each took a ‘more anti-Catholic than thou’ stance, claiming that they alone were carrying forward the true Reformation and accusing their Protestant opponents of compromising the gospel. In these polemics, ‘not being Catholic’ has become a standard of orthodox Protestantism… Anti-Catholicism becomes a subordinate confessional standard, coloring, qualifying, sometimes undermining Protestant commitment to sola Scriptura. It still does.” 9

Unconsciously, during these disputes, orthodox Protestantism functionally defined itself more by its opposition to Catholicism than by its alignment with Scripture.

The Collapse of Hierarchy into the Crisis of Doubles

Rivalries, at their core, stem from two (or more) people (or groups) desiring the same thing. Rivalries, then, stem more from how people are alike than from how they are different. Girard says, the “sacrificial crisis can be defined, therefore, as a crisis of distinctions—that is, a crisis affecting the cultural order… Order, peace, and fecundity depend on cultural distinctions; it is not these distinctions but the loss of them that gives birth to fierce rivalries and sets members of the same family or social group at one another’s throats.” 10

By dismantling the medieval hierarchy (an “external” structure of mediation that previously kept people in their distinct lanes), the Reformation placed every believer and magistrate on the same horizontal plane, turning them into rival interpreters. And as outlined above, rivalries produce twins.

The Reformed church mirrored Rome in many ways. Take, for example, the complicated bureaucratic nightmare of the medieval church of Rome. Though united in principle, Protestants argued that the church of Rome was fractured by a myriad of conflicting complexities that placed an undue burden on the individual man. But the Protestant revolution produced a mirrored image of this confusion. James Payton says:

“It is at least a horrendous anomaly that the sixteenth-century Reformation got rid of the clutter that obscured the foundation of the Christian faith, only to have Protestants cover that foundation again with the clutter of manifold divisions… In this regard, we have sown the wind and have reaped the whirlwind.” 11

Leithart adds:

“A Reformation gone wrong – a Reformation that has collapsed into traditionalism, a Reformation that persists in its centuries-long mitosis… such a Reformation is not worth preserving.” 12

This issue persists to this day. It is the common attitude of Protestants that, so long as you are doing so in the name of the Gospel, you may attack other pastors, split churches, and refuse to reunite and work through differences. Rich Lusk says:

“It’s acceptable in many Reformed circles to ruthlessly attack other ministers, split churches, refuse denominational reunion, criticize other Christians mercilessly, and basically act ‘fleshly’ (cf. Gal. 5:19ff) because, after all, the ‘gospel’ is at stake. In reality, it is the ‘gospel’ that is being flatly denied every time such attitudes and postures prevail (Gal. 2:11ff)… The Reformation dealt with the heresy of Pelagianism, but the Galatian heresy is alive and well. All too often we take an ‘us versus them’ approach to fellow believers…” 13

This issue has bothered me for years, ever since I memorized Philippians. My main takeaway from that experience was that I became sensitive to the theme of unity among believers throughout the Bible. I see it everywhere. And the more I think about Protestantism, the more I see a movement that has lost its way. When we celebrate Protestantism, we talk about reclaiming some truth buried under the fleshly confusion of human tradition. I can appreciate that. But this movement has replaced the confusion of the medieval church with something arguably worse.

The longer I go on thinking about the Reformation, the more I think back to 1 Kings 3, when King Solomon held up the flailing child in front of the two mothers who claimed the child as their own. The false mother asked that the child be cut in half, so that she didn’t have to live with the knowledge that her friend lived the life she wanted. In contrast, the child’s real mother relented, offering the child to the false mother to save her child’s life. My question, and the heart of the issue, is whether the Reformers acted like the first mother who agreed to cut the baby in half to win the rivalry against Rome, or the second mother? Even if the Reformers believed they were saving the child, the result of the last 500 years is a baby hacked into thirty thousand denominational pieces while rival mothers drink beer over their “half.”

What Was Severed? The Eucharist and the Left Hemisphere

If we look back at the Medieval Roman Catholic Church, the Eucharist originally provided society’s social glue. Ordained priests existed to serve the sacraments and build the communion of saints within a community. But around the 9th-11th centuries, controversies shifted the focus of the Eucharist away from communal participation toward speculation and reverence for the metaphysical status of the bread and wine. By the 12th century, lay Christians no longer received the wine with the bread. By the 15th century, the link between community and the Mass was largely severed, and physical proximity to the host was instead used to reinforce individual status and political power.

But even as Protestants rejected this already bad situation in their attempt to restore a communal aspect, they inadvertently created widespread individualism.

At the Colloquy of Marburg in October 1529, early Reformers couldn’t agree over the real presence of Christ in the Lord’s Supper. Both Martin Luther and Huldrych Zwingli failed to establish a unified Protestant position. On the one hand, Luther espoused a rigid realism. He believed that the bread and the wine genuinely communicated what they represented. Zwingli, by contrast, denied the real presence, reducing the elements to mere symbols. His idea wedged itself between the visible and the mystical, making him, according to J. P. Singh Uberoi, the “first philosopher… of the modern world.” 14 This opposition of the symbol from the real world, as Alexander Schmemann pointed out, divorced the sacraments from creation and unintentionally separated profane, real life from holy, sacred reality. The Church became a shell, a place that symbolizes something far away, driving a wedge between the work of the Church and the work of the real world. Leithart points out, for example, that modern deconstructionism, when traced, is simply Zwinglian Eucharistic theology operating in a linguistic realm 15.

This divorce of symbol and reality at Marburg was not just a theological dispute; it marked a profound cognitive shift in Western history. According to Iain McGilchrist’s book The Master and His Emissary, neuroscience shows that the true difference between the brain’s hemispheres lies not in what each does, but in the mode of attention and the disposition it brings to reality 16.

The right hemisphere is broad, with an open attention. It focuses on what is new, implicit, metaphorical, embodied, individual, and relational. It sees other beings as individuals to relate to rather than objects to manipulate. Reality, to the right hemisphere, delivers the direct, lived experience.

The left hemisphere, on the other hand, has a narrower, more focused attention. It tends to decontextualize and break things down into static parts and categories, reducing the living world to inanimate mechanisms and abstract concepts. It operates on a virtual copy or mental map of reality rather than reality itself. McGilchrist calls this a re-presentation of reality.

The right hemisphere experiences the living, unmediated whole of reality (which is why it is called the Master). At the same time, the left (the Emissary) is sent out to isolate specific parts, analyze them, make them explicit, and then turn them into useful concepts that are brought back to the right hemisphere, where they are re-integrated to make a richer, higher-level understanding and experience of the living whole.

McGilchrist’s premise is that in Western cultural history, the Emissary has usurped the throne of the Master.

In the late Middle Ages, the Roman Catholic Church increasingly fell into legalistic, mechanical practices in which outer rituals were divorced from inner devotion. Scholasticism had already initiated a left-hemisphere shift by attempting to define the mystery of the sacrament through the rigid mechanics of Transubstantiation. The Reformers’ initial intention was a right-hemisphere-dominated reaction: they wanted to rid themselves of corruption and experience a real, lived life in the true presence of God. However, when the Reformers rejected Transubstantiation, they couldn’t go back to a right-hemisphere way of looking at the mystery. Instead, they doubled down. Zwingli completed the left-hemisphere takeover by turning the Eucharist into an abstract, verbal metaphor. Thus, art and ritual no longer pointed toward a living, transcendent other, but instead became shadowed metaphors of those now, seemingly, far-away realities.

What began as a left-hemisphere treatment of the Eucharist has unfolded into a system of thought fraught with problems. Within many Reformed circles there is a complete void of historical memory, tradition, and physical imagery. This left-hemisphere-dominated form of thinking mistrusts the physical body and the material world. It has abstracted the church into an “invisible Church” that is everywhere and nowhere at the same time. If we cannot point to anything holy, and if holiness is all around but invisible, then it is practically nowhere. By succumbing completely to the left-hemisphere mode of thinking, the rich, living symbol of the Eucharist became an empty signifier.

Why the Reformation “Failed” and Why We Must Mourn

The goal and obvious failure of the Reformers is found in their name. Leithart says that they “did not start with a plan to found separate churches. Their goal was to reform the entire Latin church. In this they failed. The paradox is sharp, and we need to feel its point and its edge if we Protestants are to reckon honestly with our history.” 17

Leithart quotes Lee Palmer Wandel:

“In 1500, the word ‘Christian’ was univocal; by 1600, there were a variety of definitions of the word, and Christians of one sort didn’t necessarily recognize Christians of other sorts as Christians… In 1500, the Latin Mass was the church’s liturgy throughout Western Europe; by 1600, several different, mutually exclusive, Eucharistic liturgies were enacted across Europe. The division penetrated to families and neighborhoods. Catholics whose children married in non-sacramental Protestant weddings considered their own grandchildren to be bastards.”

The Reformation set out to reform the Catholic Church; instead, it fragmented and weakened Christendom, ushering in a wave of secularism and undermining the coherence and unity of the West, both politically and for the average Christian in society.

Some may say this severing of the body of Christ was necessary. Fine. But even if we accept that, why would a surgeon come in after taking the foot off of a child, call for a round of beers, and tell of his exploits? Why would we ever celebrate the severing of the visible body of Christ, the rise of secularism, and the collapse of the tangible sacred reality of Christian life?

In my mind, the only appropriate response is prayer and fasting. We must pray that the Protestant cause be carried through; we must pray that the Protestant churches unite, not only among themselves, but also with the Roman Catholic Church and the Eastern Orthodox Church. Not for the sake of unity itself, which (when placed above truth) always murders truth, but in God’s truth leading us to unity.

Footnotes

  1. Peter J. Leithart, “Excerpt from Reformation Day Sermon,” First Things, October 31, 2010, https://firstthings.com/excerpt-from-reformation-day-sermon/.
  2. For more on this, see Mark Horne, “Celebrating a Calvinist Christmas with a Clear Conscience: Is the Holiday Un-Presbyterian?,” Theopolis Institute, May 20, 2007, https://theopolisinstitute.com/celebrating-a-calvinist-christmas-with-a-clear-conscience/.
  3. Peter J. Leithart, “Exhortation, Last Sunday of Epiphany,” First Things, February 18, 2007, https://firstthings.com/exhortation-75/.
  4. For a more detailed outline of Girard’s thought, see: René Girard, I See Satan Fall Like Lightning, trans. James G. Williams (Maryknoll, N.Y.: Ottawa: Leominster, Herefordshire: Orbis, 2001), ix–xxiv.
  5. René Girard, Things Hidden Since the Foundation of the World, trans. Stephen Bann and Michael Metteer (Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 1987), 24.
  6. René Girard, Violence and the Sacred, trans. Patrick Gregory (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1977), 315.
  7. Girard, Violence and the Sacred, 92–93.
  8. Girard, Things Hidden Since the Foundation of the World, 32.
  9. Peter Leithart, “More Anti-Catholic Than Thou,” Theopolis Institute, March 28, 2017, https://theopolisinstitute.com/more-anti-catholic-than-thou/.
  10. Girard, Violence and the Sacred, 49.
  11. Peter J. Leithart, “Right Reformation,” First Things, August 7, 2010, https://firstthings.com/right-reformation/.
  12. Leithart, “Right Reformation.”
  13. Rich Lusk, “Getting the Galatian Heresy Right,” Theologia, 2003, https://hornes.org/theologia/rich-lusk/getting-the-galatian-heresy-right.
  14. Peter J. Leithart, “Marburg and Modernity,” First Things, January 1, 1992, https://firstthings.com/marburg-and-modernity/.
  15. Leithart, “Marburg and Modernity.”
  16. For more, see: Iain McGilchrist, The Master and His Emissary: The Divided Brain and the Making of the Western World (New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 2009).
  17. Peter Leithart, “How the Reformation Failed,” Substack newsletter, Notes from Beth-Elim, October 30, 2026, https://peterleithart.substack.com/p/how-the-reformation-failed.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *